clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Morning Report: Chael Sonnen defends Joe Rogan on scoring criteria, highlights damage as open to interpretation

UFC 273: Volkanovski v The Korean Zombie Zombie Photo by James Gilbert/Getty Images

Scoring in MMA was once again a hot topic this week after Joe Rogan suggested some changes to the current unified rules, which already happened to be in place. As it always does, the debate rages on.

Catching wind of Rogan’s comments about damage being a priority over control in the scoring criteria, former three-time UFC title challenger, Chael Sonnen, entered the conversation Thursday. Despite that one time Sonnen joked saying he thought you only lost the round, and not the whole fight when being finished, he’s well familiar with fighting to a decision with 20 in his 49-fight career.

As dominant as they came in the wrestling department, Sonnen believes clarity needed to be provided regarding the lack thereof about the criteria’s assessment of damage.

“Being aware of that, realizing that was a half a decade ago [when the rules were updated], realizing that the UFC champion (Aljamain Sterling) did not know enough to correct the No. 1 voice of the UFC... I gotta tell ya, I’m with them,” Sonnen said on his YouTube channel. “I’m with Sterling and Joe, and I’m well aware of what the rule is. I don’t know that I fully agree that Joe misspoke and that Sterling himself didn’t know the rule. Perhaps they did. But I still somewhat see it in their regard, I really do.

“I’m well aware that the rule says it’s damage over control but that is extremely speculative. That is very open for interpretation and how much damage takes precedence over how much control, I don’t believe you. If somebody’s on their feet, boom they land a straight, boom they land to the body. Those are the two shots, no one else hits anyone for the rest of the round. That comes out, that’s well less than a 10th of a second for those two shots to happen. The other guy takes him down and absolutely controls him. Essentially what Sterling did in his last fight to [Petr] Yan. The only damage that was done if we’re determining that damage can only be done by strikes, that gets interesting. That would make sense that the only way you can do damage is with a strike. If one guy hit the other guy twice in a round and the other guy hit them zero times in a round... Certainly, the damage must have been done by the guy who did [landed] — I don’t agree. I’m not ready to say yes. I would have to see the round.”

Applying the comparison to Sonnen himself as an MMA fighter isn’t quite reasonable as the West Linn, Oregon native was one of the best and most active ground and pound fighters of his era. The damage he dished out was always apparent via his high volume strikes, but back in his collegiate wrestling days, that was a different story.

Obviously, MMA isn’t collegiate wrestling and vice versa. But the disruptions of gameplans and implementation of frustrating an opponent is all too common in MMA and, in a way, damaging the other competitor, argues Sonnen.

Due to the complexity of a sport like MMA, many believe the scoring criteria needs to be a little bit open to interpretation the way that it is. On the other hand, straight-up clarity such as a knockdown equaling an instant 10-8 is also always an enticing idea. Ultimately, at present, it’s simply a matter of perspective using the material given.

“I have been in wrestling matches on both sides, I have done a lot of damage back in my collegiate days to my opponents,” Sonnen said. “I never hit anybody once. But if I’m being fair, I had a lot of damage be done to me in certain rounds of wrestling matches where no strikes were thrown at all. Where are you going to put ‘frustration’ in the world of damage?

“If you take a guy down and he’s trying to get up the entire time, I think Petr Yan would be a fine example. Yan was not staying down [in the Sterling rematch], he was not looking for triangles, he was not looking for armbars, he was not comfortable on his back, he was not wanting to be in that position. He was trying to get off the bottom so desperately that he turned his back. He said, ‘To hell with everything if this is what it’s going to take.’ He demonstrated a very clear preference that he did not want to be in that position. So how you gonna rate that? Where within the unified rules does it say that [damage can only be done with a strike]? It doesn’t. It says damage.”


Interim. Kai Kara-France reacts to Deiveson Figueiredo’s “plastic belt” insult: “Bro, you missed your shot.”

Matchup. Glover Teixeira respects “unpredictable” Jiri Prochazka for “crazy” striking but “can’t compare him” to Jon Jones.

Nope. Alan Belcher reveals UFC stopped him from boxing on a Roy Jones Jr. card in 2006.

Bare-Knuckle. Michael “Venom” Page vs. Mike Perry headlines Aug. 20 BKFC event in London.

Lucky. Oscar De La Hoya glad he didn’t come back to fight Vitor Belfort.


MMA Fighting’s Damon Martin chats with Luke Rockhold.

Between the Links featuring Joe Solecki.

UFC 274 Embedded 4.

Top Finishes From UFC 275 Fighters.

Best of Road To UFC Singapore | Episodes 1 & 2.

The DC Check-In with Joanna Jedrzejczyk.

Georgian wedding in America.


Heck of a Morning. MMA Fighting’s Mike Heck discusses whether or not Joanna Jedrzejczyk’s long layoff help or hurt her at UFC 275.



Book it.




Five senses of combat.

Time flies.

UFC 276 poster.



One hell of a wrestling tag team.

Is that blue steel?




Movin’ on up.

Uhh... duh.

Always ready.



It never ends.

Aussie, Aussie, Aussie.


Taneisha Tennant (4-1) vs. Olga Rubin (7-2); Invicta FC 48, July 20

Katharina Lehner (7-3) vs. Talita Bernardo (7-4); Invicta FC 48, July 20

Mallory Martin (7-5) vs. Kyra Batara (8-5); Invicta FC 48, July 20

Liana Pirosin (8-4) vs. Kristina Williams (5-3); Invicta FC 48, July 20

Amber Leibrock (5-4) vs. Morgan Frier (4-3); Invicta FC 48, July 20

Alexandre Pantoja (24-5) vs. Alex Perez (24-6); UFC 277, July 30


GSP once again reminds us why he’s the GOAT. What a jerk.

Happy Friday, enjoy the weekend, and thanks for reading!



Do the unified rules of MMA need more clarity when it comes to scoring a fight?

This poll is closed

  • 84%
    (283 votes)
  • 15%
    (51 votes)
334 votes total Vote Now

If you find something you’d like to see in the Morning Report, hit up @DrakeRiggs_ on Twitter and let him know about it. Also follow MMAFighting on Instagram and like us on Facebook.

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the MMA Fighting Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of all your fighting news from MMA Fighting