Morning Report: Georges St-Pierre says Frankie Edgar is No. 1 pound-for-pound fighter in the world

Esther Lin, MMA Fighting

For years, the debate raged across the MMA community. Who was the superior pound-for-pound fighter, Georges St-Pierre or Anderson Silva? Both men were among the sport's greatest champions; their reigns, legendary. At times, the consensus often flip-flopped depending on who fought last and how much Silva appeared to care.

But now the conversation has changed. Nearly 18 months of St-Pierre's inactivity, coupled with the astonishing rise of Jon Jones, has seen the title of the world's greatest fighter rebranded into an ‘anything you can do, I can do better' competition between Jones and Silva.

After Silva's last outing, which just so happened to be one of the most brilliant four minutes and forty seconds this writer has ever seen, "The Spider" seems to have firmly seized the pole position if you abide by the gospel of UFC President Dana White and the near-entirety of the Zuffa roster. However, in a recent interview with the Los Angeles Times, St-Pierre was asked for his own pound-for-pound list, and surprisingly, Silva only came in at third.

So St-Pierre is a confident guy and he still ranks himself and Jones above Silva; no big deal, right? Well, not exactly. Sure, Jones, came in at No. 2, but unless you read the headline of this article, you'd have never guessed who St-Pierre put atop the pedestal.

Check out an excerpt from the conversation:

If you had to rank the top three fighters in the UFC now in order, who are they?

"No. 1 is Frankie Edgar; he's the best pound-for-pound fighter we have."

Wait, he's not even a champion.

"He lost his fight to Benson Henderson only according to the judges. He was much stronger than Henderson."

OK, who else is in the top three?

"Jon Jones is No. 2, Anderson Silva's No. 3."

Star-divide

6 MUST-READ STORIES

St-Pierre ranks Edgar No. 1 pound-for-pound. Speaking to the Los Angeles Times, Georges St-Pierre surprisingly ranked former UFC lightweight champion Frankie Edgar as the No. 1 pound-for-pound fighter in the world, placing Jon Jones at No. 2 and Anderson Silva at No. 3.

Jones changing tune on Silva superfight. A day after telling Brazilian journalists that a superfight with Anderson Silva 'could happen,' UFC light heavyweight champion Jon Jones continued to bend while speaking to ESPN Brazil: "I don´t know ... Well, I don´t see it anymore as a [lose-lose situation]. Actually, now I think I would only benefit from it. (Pauses) ... But I don´t know. I really don´t know."

Koscheck vs. Diaz heating up. Following statements Cesar Gracie made to Brazilian media regarding his client, Nick Diaz's, desire to fight Josh Koscheck, "Kos" wasted no time accepting the fight over Twitter. Diaz's one-year suspension for marijuana metabolites expires on February 3, 2013.

White reportedly cuts out Palms. According to a report from the Las Vegas Review-Journal, a furious UFC President Dana White cut all ties with The Palms Casino Resort after new president Joe Magliarditi cut White's credit line in half. Notably mentioned in the story is that White's tipping habits were "legendary," as he reportedly "ran up dinner tabs of $15,000-$20,000 and tossed in $10,000 tips" up to three or four times a week, and tipped dealers more than $100,000 during one particular two-month hot streak.

Wanderlei eyeing 2013 return at 205. In an interview with Sherdog, legendary veteran Wandelei Silva revealed he'd like to return sometime early next year, either fighting at a catchweight or at light heavyweight. Silva compiled a 2-1 record in his UFC run at middleweight.

Talk to Shamrock for $11.99 a minute. Joining the likes of former New York Giants running back Reuben Droughns and Loyola Marymount standout Bo Kimble, UFC Hall of Famer Ken Shamrock has invited strangers to call him for $11.99 per minute via the Call a Champ chatline service.

Star-divide

MEDIA STEW

I have no idea why this exists, but it definitely does.

(HT: Reddit)

Star-divide

Our friends over at All Elbows put together this masterful behind-the-scenes look at the last Invicta event.

(Props to @Pegson for the find.)

Star-divide

Ladies and gentlemen, I've said this before and I'll say it again. Unless your name is actually Anderson Silva or Nick Diaz, you should never, ever act like Anderson Silva or Nick Diaz. (And where the hell did the guy at 0:45 come from?)

(HT: Bloody Elbow)

Star-divide

Just go ahead and jump to 5:25 to see this boxing match turn into an MMA fight real quick.

(HT: Bloody Elbow)

Star-divide

The connection to martial arts here is tenuous, at best. But this clip was just too much to not share.

Star-divide

IT HAS BEGUN

Star-divide

KOS VS. DIAZ

Star-divide

MORE HALLOWEEN MADNESS

Star-divide

FREEDOM

Star-divide

STAY SAFE

Star-divide

FIGHT ANNOUNCEMENTS

Announced yesterday (Monday, October 29, 2012):

Star-divide

FANPOST OF THE DAY

Today's Fanpost of the Day comes from King's_Gambit, who bluntly writes: The UFC's Ethnically-Driven Booking of UFC Macao is Stupid and Insulting

Just going to keep this short and sweet, but the more I think about it, the more I wonder....is ZUFFA really this stupid and culturally ignorant?

It's clear that they've loaded the card with Asian fighters and put an Asian guy, Cung Le, as the main eventer.

This leads me to believe that they're trying to follow what they always try and do when they enter a marketplace: pack the card with local fighters. The problem is, in this situation....only one fighter is actually Chinese. The rest are either South Korean or Japanese or, in Cung's case, Vietnamese.

Is the UFC actually dumb enough, and unprofessional enough, to believe that the Chinese fans will root for fighter just because he's...Asian? If so, they are sorely mistaken.

As someone who is of Chinese heritage and fairly well-traveled, I can say that it's hard to find a country that is more nationalist and more proud of its history than China. Expecting Chinese fans to feel as though a South Korean fighter were one of their own would be like, I don't know, expecting American fans to cheer for a French fighter due to feelings of ethnic camaraderie.

And don't even get me started on the Japanese fighters. As I said, it's hard to find a culture that keeps its history as close to its heart as China. For instance, historical dramas have remained a hugely popular genre of entertainment for generations. Given the acrimonious history between China and Japan, expecting Chinese fans to cheer for Japanese fighters simply because they're Asian is nothing short of insulting. You'd almost be better off choosing a fighter of any nationality BUT Japan. It's an amazing bit of ignorance on ZUFFA's part.

The thing is, even if ZUFFA isn't aware of the fact that, shockingly, the Chinese don't view other Asian nationalities as one and the same, Cung Le does. Every time an interviewer asks him whether he's excited to fight in China, clearly hoping for a racially driven answer, Cung skirts around it, focusing instead on his sanshou, saying that he's proud to fight in the birthplace of his art, hoping that the Chinese fans will root for him on that basis and connect with him on those grounds. Because Cung knows that as a Vietnamese-American, as far as having ethnic appeal to the Chinese fans, he might as well be Brazilian. Perhaps to the American ZUFFA brass, a Vietnamese guy who practices sanshou is "close enough" to being Chinese but, shockingly, it doesn't work that way in reality.

And don't even get me started on the UFC's hiring a Korean ring-girl, as though no Chinese girls could be located. The Japanese fans got a Japanese girl but when it comes to the Chinese fans, again, all Asians are one and the same, seemingly.

Found something you'd like to see in the Morning Report? Just hit me on Twitter @shaunalshatti and we'll include it in tomorrow's column.

More from MMA Fighting

In This Article

Events
Fighters
X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join MMA Fighting

You must be a member of MMA Fighting to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at MMA Fighting. You should read them.

Join MMA Fighting

You must be a member of MMA Fighting to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at MMA Fighting. You should read them.

Spinner

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_5349_tracker